Campus Superstar

[neolc71]

Any comments on Campus Superstar as compared to Project Superstar?

And comments on judges of Campus Superstar...are they qualified or give constructive comments?

[guppy]

i prefer campus superstar to project superstar. probably bcos the atmosphere is different.

when it comes to judges, imho, an organiser can decide who to judge since it's their show. so, if one finds any part of a system not justified, one shld find another competition. there're many other ways to the same point as long as we belief and continue to try

that's my general view. specifically for campus superstar, i think it's quite balanced. there is a vocal teacher (production), a songwriter/singer (production/product) and a star dj (end user). the former 2 are better with technics and the latter, better with the market.

just my 2 cents worth

[odachek]

i support campus superstar as long as the winner is talented, meaning can compose songs and sing. just like utada hikaru when she's just a teen but can compose nice songs eg. first love...